Children are the living messages we send to a time we will not see – Neil Postman

Further amunition to homeschool in the war on teachers

This is the T34, a Russian tank, highly significant in the battles at Stalingrad, the bulge and Berlin.

So, a news story broke here last week. Apparently, they want to test, not only the literacy and numeracy skills of teachers, they also want to test their ‘passion‘. While I acknowledge, and I am sure many of my students would too, that there are many teachers for whom the passion for their work is long since passed, I wonder how they will test this ‘passion’. Anyone who’s been a teacher, particularly a teacher of a slippery subject in the humanities, will know it’s awfully easy to fake a belief in something. Paying lip service to a desire to teach, and actually having a passion for the job, are two very different ideas. As the response in The Conversation noted:

Under the proposed rules, prospective teachers will need to undergo emotional aptitude tests before they begin their training.

The idea has intuitive appeal and testing emotional intelligence remains a “hot topic” in psychology circles. But it is also a slippery construct and can be difficult to test.

This doesn’t mean the idea doesn’t have merit, but let governments and education faculties be warned, testing emotional intelligence will not be easy.

(Grieve, 2013).

I wonder if this isn’t some more pre-election spin on the teacher bashing debate that’s been happening in this country since at least the 1990s, probably earlier. I say the 1990s because that’s when, as a student, I learned how undervalued and under-resourced the teaching profession was.

It also plays into my interest in home education. I don’t understand why people think it odd that some parents home educate. I mean, if you want to paint teachers as inadequte, if you want to position the profession through discourses of failure, in particular a failure of literacy and numeracy, then what else would a parent do but think, “my goodness, I need to take this into my own hands!”?

It seems illogical to me that the government doesn’t address the real problems, and these, in my opinion, go far beyond the classroom teacher. Structural problems with education, a failure to meet the genuine needs of a changed group of students for whom industrial models of education are no longer suitable or appropriate, are the real problems with education. No passion test could ever be devised to solve structural problems which are ignored for a quick media grab around failing teachers.

Real reform is needed, but I don’t think that is compatible with a three-year election cycle.


3 Responses to “Further amunition to homeschool in the war on teachers”

  1. sage_brush

    Unfortunately, good teachers are rarer and rarer. The reasons for home schooling can not be compartmentalized into a peer reviewed document – nor can the average academic ever grasp the profundity that actual home schoolers when educating their children. Emotional aptitude tests? Will it never cease? ??

    No one can question the intellectualism of our nations founders. Their writings prove their IQ’s to be in the genius rank. So what has happened? Where is the academic greatness, which once was the norm, even in grade school?

    Look at this quotation from Yale University’s 1636 Student Guidelines:

    “All the scholars are required to live a religious and blameless life according to the rules of God’s Word, diligently reading the Holy Scriptures, that fountain of Divine light and truth, and constantly attending all the duties of religion.”

    Certainly, teacher inadequacy is one of the charges – but the reasons are so far reaching in scope – that no explanation will satisfy the detractors of home schooling. For our family it is a deeply Spiritual commitment; the mere idea of exposing our precious ones to the moral abyss endemic to government schools – is completely untenable. Nothing is more important than teaching them about the Lord. Nothing. Paganism and moral relativism are the standards of public education now. When Jesus Christ is disallowed – anything goes. When we abandon Him – we revert to savagery.

    Ephesians 6: 4

    King James Version (KJV)

    And, ye fathers, provoke not your children to wrath: but bring them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.


  2. Winfred Heldreth

    There certainly is an abundance of homeschooling information available and this is a good thing… for the most part… as long as you don’t get bogged down in overload and suffer paralysis by analysis. There are a lot of wonderful articles and tips to help you insure your homeschool success.’,;-

    Catch ya later


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: